A tweet reads, “This is the Chief Designer for Balenciaga, Lotta Volkova. Enough said. They knew exactly what they were doing” and features an image of a woman dressed in red holding two red-painted dolls. The News Literacy Project has added a label that says, “UNRELATED PHOTO.”

#Illuminati

#Miscaptioned

#ConspiratorialThinking

A tweet reads, “This is the Chief Designer for Balenciaga, Lotta Volkova. Enough said. They knew exactly what they were doing” and features an image of a woman dressed in red holding two red-painted dolls. The News Literacy Project has added a label that says, “UNRELATED PHOTO.”

#Illuminati

#Miscaptioned

#ConspiratorialThinking

Miscaptioned photo spreads Balenciaga fashion controversy

The luxury fashion brand Balenciaga found itself embroiled in controversy after publishing an advertising campaign featuring children with teddy bears dressed in what appeared to be bondage gear. But bad faith actors have distorted the situation with a spate of false posts. Let’s look at the facts.

Quick Look

  • No

    This is not a photo of Lotta Volkova.

  • No

    Volkova is not the chief designer at Balenciaga (she left the company in 2018) and had no part in the company’s recent advertising campaigns.

  • Yes

    This is a photo of a fashion model on a runway showcasing the collection of designer Sheguang Hu during Mercedes-Benz China Fashion Week 2016.

  • Yes

    Another recent Balenciaga ad campaign created controversy by showing printed material related to a 2008 U.S. Supreme Court decision on child pornography.

The Takeaway

Misinformation often plays on strong emotions. When an incident makes people angry, propagandists spread rumors that tap into and exploit that anger.

In November, after Balenciaga’s ads attracted controversy, a miscaptioned photo went viral with false claims that it depicted one of the company’s chief designers in a devil-like outfit holding a pair of dolls painted blood red. The misleading photo was part of a budding conspiratorial narrative that Balenciaga is involved in devil worship. Many conspiracy theorists took things even further, trying to connect Balenciaga with antisemitic illuminati beliefs.

Balenciaga apologized for the advertisements, stating that the company “strongly condemn(s) child abuse” and it was not their intent “to include (child abuse) in our narrative,” as well as admitting to a “series of grievous errors.”

The 5 Factors

We’ve determined that this viral rumor is misleading or false based on its failure to pass the following credibility factors. Please note that these factors do not represent degrees of falsehood. A post that fails a single factor is generally just as false as a post that fails all five.

Snapshot

  • Source

  • Evidence

  • Context

  • Authenticity
  • Reasoning
Source

Has it been posted or confirmed by a credible source?

No.

This image was widely spread by conspiracy theorists seeking to stir up controversy.

Evidence

Is there evidence that proves the claim?

No.

A reverse image search reveals this image was originally taken in 2016 and shows a model who is not affiliated with Balenciaga at a fashion show in China. Fact-checkers also spoke with Volkova, who confirmed she has not worked with the company since 2018 and had been a stylist there, not a top designer.

Context

Is the context accurate?

No.

In its original context, this photo shows a model at a fashion show in 2016. This photo was stripped of this original context and miscaptioned to generate controversy.

Authenticity

Is it authentic?

N/A

Reasoning

Is it based on solid reasoning?

N/A