04.13.2023

#HillaryClinton
#RonDeSantis
#GuiltByAssociation
#AssociationFallacy
#AI
#FabricatedContent
#Deepfake

#HillaryClinton
#RonDeSantis
#GuiltByAssociation
#AssociationFallacy
#AI
#FabricatedContent
#Deepfake
04.13.2023
Hillary Clinton did not endorse Ron DeSantis for president
A digitally altered video supposedly created as a joke appears to show former Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton endorsing Florida Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis for president. But the video is a deepfake manipulation. Let’s look at the facts.
Quick Look
- No
This is not an authentic video of Clinton endorsing DeSantis.
- Yes
This video is an algorithmically generated deepfake video based on genuine footage of a December 2021 NBC News interview with Clinton.
- Yes
The video’s creator is listed as “Ramble Rants” and the words “Hail Hydra” — a reference to Marvel Comics superhero Captain America — appear at the end of the clip, both of which are clues that this is satire and not real.
The Takeaway
This video plays into the guilt by association fallacy — when a person or group is demonized due to a seeming connection with an already demonized person or group. In this case, the video creates a fictional scenario in which DeSantis, a potential Republican presidential candidate and challenger to former President Donald Trump, is endorsed by Clinton, a former Democratic candidate and a regular target of Trump and other conservatives.
As AI technology advances and becomes increasingly capable of creating realistic content, social media users need to exercise skepticism when scrolling through their feeds. These AI tools can make even the most obviously satirical content (would Clinton really say “Hail Hydra” during an interview?) appear quite convincing on first glance. Remember, when encountering sensational claims online, it’s always a good idea to seek out a second source that can add context to the content.
The 5 Factors
We’ve determined that this viral rumor is misleading or false based on its failure to pass the following credibility factors. Please note that these factors do not represent degrees of falsehood. A post that fails a single factor is generally just as false as a post that fails all five.
Snapshot
Authenticity
Source
Evidence
Reasoning
- Context
Is the context accurate?
N/A
The Techniques
Website
Tutorial: Reverse image search
Website
News Lit Quiz: Should you share it?
Website
Is it legit? Five steps for vetting a news source
Website
Tutorial: Lateral reading
Featured Fact checks
Izz Scott LaMadgeleine, Snopes
Mikael Thalen, Daily Dot