10.03.2024

#DonaldTrump
#JoeBiden
#NaturalDisasters
#ArtificialIntelligence
#FalseContext

#DonaldTrump
#JoeBiden
#NaturalDisasters
#ArtificialIntelligence
#FalseContext
10.03.2024
False Hurricane Helene rumors spread rapidly in storm’s wake
Natural disasters like Hurricane Helene, which caused more than 180 deaths as well as widespread flooding and damage throughout the southeastern United States in September 2024, allow purveyors of misinformation to spread falsehoods, such as this fabricated image showing former President Donald Trump wading through floodwaters and this out-of-context photograph of President Joe Biden lounging on the beach. Let’s look at the facts.
Quick Look
- No
This is not a genuine photograph of former President Donald Trump wading through floodwaters to aid recovery efforts after Hurricane Helene.
- Yes
This image was created with artificial intelligence.
- Yes
Trump did survey hurricane damage in Georgia after the storm.
- No
This photograph does not show President Joe Biden lounging on a beach in Delaware during Hurricane Helene.
- Yes
The photograph was taken in August 2024.
- Yes
Biden did travel to his beach house in Rehoboth Beach, Delaware, the weekend of the storm, but he was in contact with local officials, declared a state of emergency, and traveled to hurricane-hit states in the days following Hurricane Helene.
The Takeaway
Breaking national news events are frequently targeted by partisan opportunists aiming to score quick political points. In the wake of Hurricane Helene, for example, an AI-generated image and an out-of-context photograph misrepresenting the actions of former President Donald Trump and President Joe Biden spread widely online. These falsehoods can slip by undetected for many viewers since they circulate during a time of information overload and appear to confirm preconceived political biases. Learning to pause and critically examine these claims allows people time to uncover additional context. The image of Trump, for example, was not credited to a photographer (it is AI-generated) and the Biden photograph was taken about a month before the storm.
It’s also important to remember that memes are not news. After encountering a sensational social media post online, take a moment to do some additional research. Did Trump wade through floodwaters? Did Biden ignore the storm to go on vacation? Some quick lateral reading can provide important context.
The 5 Factors
We’ve determined that this viral rumor is misleading or false based on its failure to pass the following credibility factors. Please note that these factors do not represent degrees of falsehood. A post that fails a single factor is generally just as false as a post that fails all five.
Snapshot
Authenticity
Source
Evidence
- Context
- Reasoning
Is the context accurate?
N/A
Is it based on solid reasoning?
N/A
The Techniques
Website
Is it legit? Five steps for vetting a news source
Website
Tutorial: Lateral reading
Featured Fact checks
Samatha Putterman, PolitiFact
Ophélie Dénommée-Marchand, LeadStories